The Catch-22 Preventing Productive Discourse For Nearly a Century
In 1968, during the Democratic and Republican national conventions, William F. Buckley Jr. and Gore Vidal held 10 televised debates.
In these debates, Vidal avoided many topics and spent his time provoking Buckley as best he could, which culminated in Buckley’s now-infamous retort:
“Now listen, you queer, stop calling me a crypto-Nazi or I’ll sock you in the goddamn face and you’ll stay plastered.”
Buckley, a conservative who had served in the Army during the Second World War, had finally let Vidal under his skin. Disrespecting his military service after several nights of ribbing was a bridge too far for him.
He regretted it until the day he died. He felt it was an irrevocable stain on his otherwise pristine track record of shrugging off such attacks on his character. He was guilty of giving the left what they wanted.
It occurred to me today what a ridiculous double standard that was to begin with. Had the roles been reversed, and it was Buckley who spent day after day insulting a WWII veteran on national television, calling him names and likening Vidal to Hitler, before Vidal finally snapped and called Buckley a “queer” instead, no one would’ve considered the word a slur.
But because it was a conservative who slipped up and said it to a darling ultra-liberal, it was apparently something to be ashamed of. How dare he become tired enough of being compared to the Nazis that he uttered a word which was only offensive because of who was saying it?
Some things never change. It’s been this way for 60 years. If you’re on the right, they’re allowed to call you a Nazi and every name in the book. They’ll say it on the news, on talk shows, in the papers—but don’t you dare call them something equally repugnant back. No, if they said it, it would be fine. In fact, Vidal went on to do just that. He wrote books and gave interviews insinuating Buckley was in fact a “queer” himself for decades. When he did it though, it was portrayed as clearly justified, not obscene.
Almost every right-wing presidential candidate has been publicly called a Nazi since. From Barry Goldwater to Donald Trump, the media plays right into it. It’s apparently so beyond reproach that to retaliate with defamatory remarks of their own is permission to continue the approved abuse. They can do it to you, but you can’t do it back, or they’re right to have done it in the first place. The Catch-22 preventing productive discourse for nearly a century.