Lindsay Clancy appeared via Zoom from Tewksbury Hospital for a hearing Tuesday in Plymouth Superior Court in Brockton. C
|

Judge Denies Lindsay Clancy’s Bid to Dismiss Triple-Murder Case

Photo: Plymouth Superior Court, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy's request to dismiss the triple-murder charges against her on Monday.

The decision also rejected a defense bid to probe the holdout juror from the first trial and set aside media reports on that juror as evidence. Sullivan found that prosecutors had not shown out-of-court statements would likely taint the trial or the jury pool.

Sullivan turned down the prosecution request for a gag order but said prosecutors could renew that request if circumstances change before the new trial. He also reminded defense lawyer Kevin Reddington of ethical duties under state professional conduct rules.

Clancy is due back in court on Nov. 16. Prosecutors have said they intend to retry the case but have not chosen whether to keep the original charges or seek lesser ones.

The judge ended the first trial in a mistrial on Sept. 4, after jurors said one holdout was keeping them from a unanimous verdict.

Defense lawyers had argued that Sullivan should have questioned the holdout juror or removed that juror instead of ending the trial. Prosecutors under Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz said the judge handled the impasse properly.

Clancy's lawyers have said she suffered from postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings and should be found not guilty by reason of insanity. Prosecutors have acknowledged her mental health issues but maintain that she acted deliberately.

Verified Facts
  • Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy's motion to dismiss her triple-murder case on Monday. (ABC News, New York Post, The Guardian, BBC News, The Independent)
  • The decision clears the way for a potential retrial of Lindsay Clancy. (ABC News)
  • Judge William Sullivan denied a motion to investigate the holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy's previous trial. (ABC News)
  • Judge William Sullivan denied a prosecution request for a gag order in the Lindsay Clancy case. (ABC News, The Independent)
  • Judge William Sullivan rejected evidence about the holdout juror that came to light in the media after the mistrial was declared. (ABC News)
  • Judge William Sullivan concluded that prosecutors failed to prove that out-of-court statements pose a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing the outcome of the trial or prejudicing the jury venire. (ABC News)
  • Judge William Sullivan noted that prosecutors could ask for a gag order again if the circumstances change ahead of a new trial. (ABC News)
  • Judge William Sullivan reminded defense lawyer Kevin Reddington about the ethical obligations in the state's rules of professional conduct. (ABC News)
  • Lindsay Clancy is due back in court on Nov. 16. (ABC News, The Guardian, BBC News, The Independent)
  • The judge on 4 September declared a mistrial after the jury reported that a holdout juror was preventing it from reaching a unanimous verdict. (The Guardian, BBC News)
  • Lindsay Clancy cut herself with a knife and jumped from a second-story window in an attempt to end her own life, leaving her paralyzed. (The Guardian)
  • Lindsay Clancy's lawyers have argued she was in the throes of postpartum psychosis and should be found not guilty by reason of insanity. (The Guardian, BBC News)
  • Defense lawyers argued that Sullivan acted prematurely in declaring a mistrial and should have pursued a viable alternative. (The Guardian, BBC News, The Independent)
  • Prosecutors under Plymouth county district attorney Timothy Cruz countered that the judge handled the jury impasse appropriately. (The Guardian)
  • Prosecutors say the killings were intentional. (BBC News)
  • Prosecutors have acknowledged that Clancy had mental health problems but said she acted deliberately and understood her actions were wrong. (The Independent)
  • Prosecutors said they intend to retry Clancy but haven’t settled on whether they will pursue the same charges or opt for a reduced charge. (The Independent)
  • Clancy's attorney Kevin Reddington gave interviews during the trial while prosecutors generally didn't speak to reporters. (The Independent)
  • Clancy’s lawyers argued that a gag order would amount to an unconstitutional restraint on speech. (The Independent)
  • Sullivan pushed back on the defense claim that the holdout juror failed to follow the court's instruction on the law. (ABC News)
  • Clancy's lawyers argued that the lone holdout juror in favor of convicting her should have been probed further during deliberations. (New York Post)
  • That juror potentially could have been dismissed and replaced with another jury, allowing the panel to reach a verdict, Clancy's lawyers argued. (New York Post)
  • Citing jury notes that stated the holdout juror was not following the law on reasonable doubt despite the judge's instructions, defense lawyers said Sullivan should have instead questioned the holdout and potentially removed the juror. (The Guardian)
  • Her lawyers argued the judge should have removed the single juror who favored conviction and allowed jury deliberations to continue. (The Independent)
  • Sullivan disagreed, saying he saw no other option than declaring a mistrial. (The Independent)
  • Judge William Sullivan said he would like the new trial to begin. (ABC News, The Guardian, BBC News)
  • Clancy's defence team requested dismissal of the case after her first trial ended in a mistrial, when a jury failed to reach a consensus. (BBC News)
Sources

Similar Posts