California Voters Reject One-Time Billionaire Tax Measure
Photo: Mackinacbridge, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
California voters rejected Proposition 40, a measure that would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the assets of residents worth more than $1.1 billion, NBC News projected on Monday.
The proposal called for 90% of any revenue to fund healthcare and would have applied to anyone living in the state as of Jan. 1, 2026.
It would have marked the first U.S. billionaire tax if approved, NBC News said.
Opponents spent heavily on ads, with funding from the billionaires targeted by the measure, especially in Silicon Valley, according to NBC News. Billionaires such as Google co-founder Sergey Brin and venture capitalist Peter Thiel backed opposition.
Outgoing Gov. Gavin Newsom opposed Proposition 40 and backed Proposition 42. He warned that a state-only wealth tax would push wealthy residents to leave and reduce other tax collections. The California Medical Association and California Teachers Association also opposed the measure.
Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Ro Khanna supported the proposal and held rallies ahead of the vote. The California Democratic Party and SEIU Healthcare Workers West backed it as well.
Many progressives who favor higher taxes on the wealthy opposed the measure because it was a one-time levy rather than a permanent one and because it focused revenue mainly on healthcare, NBC News reported.
Critics in both parties said the tax would prompt wealthy residents to leave the state and reduce other tax collections, according to NBC News. CBS News said the campaign shattered spending records for a tax-related measure in California.
Verified Facts
- NBC News projected the rejection on Monday. (NBC News)
- The rejection deals a blow to progressives who championed the proposal according to NBC News. (NBC News)
- Proposition 40 sharply divided Democrats in the state and nationally. (NBC News)
- Proposition 40 faced a barrage of ad spending funded by the billionaires it would have affected, particularly in Silicon Valley according to NBC News. (NBC News)
- Proposition 40 would require California to spend 90% of the created revenue on healthcare. (NBC News)
- The taxes in Proposition 40 would apply retroactively to anyone living in the state as of Jan. 1, 2026. (NBC News)
- Proposition 40 would have been the first enactment of a billionaire tax in the U.S. according to NBC News. (NBC News)
- Critics in both parties argued that the tax would prompt wealthy Californians to flee the state in droves according to NBC News. (NBC News)
- Critics argued that wealthy Californians fleeing would dry up broader tax revenue streams and create more budget problems according to NBC News. (NBC News)
- Democratic opponents of Proposition 40 included outgoing Gov. Gavin Newsom. (NBC News)
- Sen. Bernie Sanders was a notable backer of Proposition 40. (NBC News)
- Rep. Ro Khanna was a notable backer of Proposition 40. (NBC News)
- Bernie Sanders and Ro Khanna held several rallies in the state ahead of Election Day. (NBC News)
- Opponents of Proposition 40 held a staggering upper hand on the airwaves according to NBC News. (NBC News)
- Proposition 42 proposed banning any new taxes on assets, including investment accounts and property and restricting increases in retroactive taxes. (NBC News)
- Voters in California have rejected a tax on the state's wealthiest residents, CBS News projects. (CBS News)
- The campaign split traditional allies and shattered spending records for a tax-related measure in California according to CBS News. (CBS News)
- The proposal came at a time when other states and federal policymakers are debating how to tax extreme wealth and finance public services, and how Proposition 40 was viewed as a bellwether according to CBS News. (CBS News)
- The vote was framed by supporters as part of a broader struggle over economic inequality and the political influence of the billionaire class according to CBS News. (CBS News)
- Proponents argue that billionaires can accumulate substantial wealth from the stock market and business valuations without paying income tax on those gains until they are realized. (CBS News)
- Proponents contend that those who have benefited the most from the state's robust economy should contribute more toward public services. (CBS News)
- The measure was supported by the California Democratic Party and labor unions including SEIU Healthcare Workers West, the principal sponsor of the measure. (CBS News)
- The measure was opposed by Gov. Gavin Newsom. (CBS News)
- The measure was opposed by major healthcare and professional organizations such as the California Medical Association and California Teachers Association. (CBS News)
- Newsom has advocated for taxing billionaires at the federal level. (CBS News)
- Newsom says a California-only wealth tax would be limited to funding healthcare and not other needs. (CBS News)
- Opponents of the measure claim that the initiative does not provide guarantees about how the money would be allocated among providers and services. (CBS News)
- California voters have officially rejected a controversial, would-be historic wealth tax on billionaires. (New York Post)
- The proposal was rejected in most counties across the Golden State. (New York Post)
- California Governor Gavin Newsom was also skeptical about the proposition, warning that it would drive out the state’s wealthiest residents and tech founders. (New York Post)
- Newsom backed Proposition 42 which prohibits a wealth tax like Prop 40 and bans any new taxes on personal property. (New York Post)
- California voters have voted to reject a wealth tax on its billionaires. (BBC News)
- The wealth tax faced fierce opposition, including from Google co-founder Sergey Brin, as well as California Governor Gavin Newsom and labour unions. (BBC News)
- Newsom, whose tenure as governor is coming to an end, had expressed concerns that the measure could cause the wealthy to leave the state and drive out their crucial income tax revenue. (BBC News)
- The bruising campaign over Proposition 40 was the most expensive in state history and witness to back-and-forth dealing from tech billionaires and democratic leaders, including Gavin Newsom, the governor, who steadfastly opposed the measure. (The Guardian)
- It was sponsored by the healthcare union SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, and dictated that the proceeds from the tax would fund healthcare programs, along with some education and food assistance. (The Guardian)
- The state’s major unions, and progressive politicians such as Bernie Sanders, the Vermont senator, and Ro Khanna, a California congressman, backed Prop 40. (The Guardian)
- Both the Democratic and Republican candidates for governor, as well as organizations such as Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California, a lobbying branch of the healthcare group, opposed it. (The Guardian)
- If either measure received more yes votes than Prop 40, they would stop the billionaire tax from taking effect – even if it passed. (The Guardian)
- Many of California’s unions and Democratic-aligned advocacy groups opposed Proposition 40. (NBC News)
- A coalition received contributions from several billionaires. (NBC News)
- Other groups got millions from Google co-founder Sergey Brin. (NBC News)
- A coalition of billionaires organized in opposition to the measure, such as Google co-founder Sergey Brin and venture capitalist Peter Thiel. (CBS News)
- Millions of dollars were poured into opposing the proposal, including major spending from Google co-founder Sergey Brin and Palantir co-founder Peter Thiel. (New York Post)
- Prop 40’s most vocal critics, however, were the state’s billionaires. (The Guardian)
Sources
- NBC News: California voters reject new tax on billionaires in a blow to the left
- CBS News: California voters reject Prop. 40 billionaire wealth tax, CBS News projects
- New York Post: California voters officially reject controversial billionaire tax in setback for progressive agenda
- BBC News: Californians reject Prop 40 wealth tax for billionaires
- The Guardian: California voters fail to pass proposed one-time tax on billionaires’ wealth